PCH-1 Chorus vs Competitors: Sound ComparisonThe PCH-1 Chorus is a compact chorus pedal aimed at players seeking classic modulation tones with modern usability. This article compares the PCH-1’s sound character, controls, and versatility against several notable competitors in the chorus pedal market: the Boss CE-2W, Electro‑Harmonix Small Clone, TC Electronic Stereo Chorus, and MXR M234 Analog Chorus. The goal is to give practical listening- and usage-oriented guidance so you can decide which pedal best suits your instrument, style, and rig.
Quick summary (sound personalities)
- PCH-1 Chorus: Warm, smooth, slightly bright; modern clarity with classic lushness.
- Boss CE-2W: Vintage, thick, slightly darkened analog warmth.
- Electro‑Harmonix Small Clone: Dense, watery, strong modulation character.
- TC Electronic Stereo Chorus: Clean, versatile, studio-grade clarity; wide stereo image.
- MXR M234 Analog Chorus: Warm, punchy, simple and musical analog voice.
Design and control layout (impact on sound shaping)
PCH-1: Typically includes Rate, Depth, Mix (or Level), and sometimes a Tone or Hi‑Cut control. The controls give straightforward access to chorus amount and modulation speed while preserving signal clarity. A dedicated Tone/Hi‑Cut (if present) helps tame brightness for amp-forward rigs.
Boss CE-2W: Emulates classic CE-1/CE-2 flavors with Rate and Depth. Fewer controls but the character is baked into the circuit—easy to dial classic sounds quickly.
Small Clone: Simple two-knob layout (Rate, Depth) with an internal trim for depth. Its simplicity encourages experimentation with the two parameters and often yields strong, characterful results without fuss.
TC Electronic Stereo Chorus: Often features Rate, Depth, FX Level, Tone, and programmable presets or a tap tempo/expansion. The extensive control set allows precise sculpting and stereo imaging.
MXR M234: Usually Rate, Depth, and a Level or Tone control. It focuses on analog-style warmth and musicality without extra frills.
Core sound comparison
-
Tonal Weight and Warmth
- PCH-1: Balanced warmth—not overly dark, retains presence. Works well with both clean and slightly overdriven tones.
- CE-2W: Warm and thick, leaning darker than the PCH-1.
- Small Clone: Thick and wet, sometimes perceived as more modulated/wobbly.
- TC Stereo: Neutral and clear, less inherent warmth, more transparent.
- MXR M234: Warm and punchy, close to CE-2W but with its own mid punch.
-
Modulation Character (LFO shape, depth feel)
- PCH-1: Smooth sine-like LFO with even modulation; adjustable depth feels musical without warbling.
- CE-2W: Rounded, classic LFO—characterful and slightly slower-feeling.
- Small Clone: Strong, sometimes chorus/vibrato borderline at high depth — very pronounced character.
- TC Stereo: Clean, precise LFO with options for wide/stereo spread.
- MXR M234: Classic analog LFO flavor—musical and responsive to dynamics.
-
Stereo Imaging
- PCH-1: Likely offers a modest stereo spread (stereo models) with a natural width.
- CE-2W: Mono-focused vintage tone; stereo emulation in some modes.
- Small Clone: Traditionally mono; extremely focused center image.
- TC Stereo: Wide stereo field — excellent for studio and ambient rigs.
- MXR M234: May include stereo outputs on some versions; moderate spread.
-
Presence with Distortion/Overdrive
- PCH-1: Maintains clarity and definition with drive; chorus sits around the signal without clouding.
- CE-2W: Thickens distortion—can get muddy if pushed too far.
- Small Clone: Can become very watery with heavy gain.
- TC Stereo: Stays articulate with gain stages; excellent for layered textures.
- MXR M234: Generally sits well with overdrive; adds analog richness.
Use-case recommendations
- For vintage, lush chorus tones (70s/80s): Boss CE-2W or MXR M234.
- For distinct, characterful modulation (indie, shoegaze): Electro‑Harmonix Small Clone.
- For clean, studio-grade, wide stereo chorus (ambient, pop): TC Electronic Stereo Chorus.
- For a versatile, modern classic voice that balances warmth and clarity: PCH-1 Chorus.
Practical listening tests to try
- Clean single‑coil strat — slow rate, medium depth: compare how each fills the space without losing attack.
- Humbucker neck — slow rate, high depth: check warmth vs. muddiness.
- Overdriven amp — medium rate, low depth: observe clarity and interaction with gain.
- Stereo rig — max depth and rate sweep: evaluate width and movement.
Final thoughts
The PCH-1 Chorus sits between classic analog voice and modern clarity: it won’t be as vintage-dark as the CE-2W or as wildly characterful as the Small Clone, but it offers a versatile, musical chorus that performs well across clean and driven tones. If you want wide stereo textures and studio-grade flexibility, the TC Stereo is the stronger choice; if you want a distinct vintage identity, pick CE-2W or MXR M234. Choose the PCH-1 when you want a reliable, balanced chorus that translates across styles and rigs.
Leave a Reply